Episode 292: Holy Anxiety: The Understandable Underbelly of Scrupulosity

Scrupulosity often looks like devotion — but when fear takes over, even our spiritual life can become consumed by doubt, checking, and the search for certainty. In this episode, Dr. Greg Bottaro continues the series on OCPD and perfectionism, exploring the difference between a healthy conscience and a scrupulous one, why mercy can be hard to trust, and how our experiences shape the way we see God. Holiness was never meant to be an endless audit — it was meant to lead us into relationship with the One who loves us.

Key Topics:

• How reciting the truth about mercy in your head does nothing to change what your body still believes
• Why certainty about being forgiven is the one thing this pattern can never actually get
• Why confession, meant to bring peace, can quietly become just another form of checking
• How the voice you call your conscience might actually be a punishing voice in disguise
• Why the face you're afraid God is making at you was never really His
• How the saints wrestled with scrupulosity — and what finally brought them peace wasn't more proof
• Why doing this work alone almost always makes the pattern worse
• How the way out can feel too easy to trust

Learn More:

• Previous episodes in this series on Obsessive Compulsive Personality Patterns:
  • Ep. #290: "I'm Only Loved When I'm Perfect": The Lie Fueling Obsessive-Compulsive Personality Disorder
  • Ep. #291: OCPD and Scrupulosity: How the Worship of Rules and Control Leads to the Loneliness of Certainty
• Episode referenced on spiritual bypassing: Why "Everything Happens for a Reason" Isn't Working: The Holy Words We Use to Avoid Healing
• Join us at the Summit of Integration this October in Dallas — launching the Year of St. John Paul II
• Start of the Being Human series on the Antisocial Defense Patterns:
  • Ep. #281: Control or Be Controlled: The Devastating Wounds Behind Antisocial Behavioral Patterns
• Start of the Being Human series on the Borderline Defense Patterns:
  • Ep. #269: BORDERLINE: The Push-Pull Between a Fear of Abandonment and Annihilation
• Start of the Being Human series on the Histrionic Defense Patterns:
  • Ep. #274: To Be Loved Is to Perform: Inside the Histrionic Compulsion for Attention and Validation
• Start of the Being Human series on the Dependent Defense Patterns:
  • Ep. #265: Jerry Maguire, Gollum, and the Fear of Not Existing
• Start of the Being Human series on the Narcissistic Defense Patterns:
  • Ep. #261: Narcissism and the Terror of Being Ordinary
• Need help? Schedule a free CatholicPsych consultation.
• Want to help? Learn more about our Certification in Professional Accompaniment.

Follow Us on Socials: Instagram | Facebook | YouTube | Twitter (X) | LinkedIn