Theology in the Raw artwork

· 1h 3m· Episode 1448

Church Trauma, Wounded Pastors, and the Apostle Paul: Scot McKnight & Adrienne Gibson

Theology in the Raw

About this episode

Was the Apostle Paul traumatized by the church he helped establish? New Testament scholar Scot McKnight and licensed professional counselor Adrienne Gibson join me to explore church trauma, pastoral burnout, and what Paul’s relationship with the Corinthians reveals about wounded ministry leaders.

We’ve rightly become more aware of spiritual abuse and the harm caused by church leaders. But what happens when pastors, ministry leaders, and volunteers are hurt by the people they serve? Drawing on their book, Traumatized Church: What Paul’s Relationship with the Corinthian Church Teaches Us about Helping Those Who Are Hurting, Scot and Adrienne bring biblical scholarship and counseling experience into this often overlooked conversation.

We discuss what trauma actually means, how it differs from discomfort, why the same experience affects people differently, and how biblical teaching can reopen wounds when Scripture has previously been used to justify abuse. Adrienne also explains why pastors need boundaries and offers practical ways to respond when someone’s past pain enters a present conversation.

Finally, Scot walks us through seven criticisms directed at Paul and explains why he reads 2 Corinthians 10–13 as the words of a deeply wounded apostle. It’s a conversation about caring for hurting people—including those who spend their lives caring for everyone else.

Join the Theology in the Raw community for bonus “Extra Innings” conversations and more: https://www.patreon.com/theologyintheraw


CHAPTERS

00:00 Was Paul traumatized by the church?

00:37 Introducing Scot McKnight and Adrienne Gibson

02:41 What is trauma?

04:23 Why the same experience affects people differently

05:47 How biblical scholarship and trauma counseling came together

11:31 What ministry leaders need to understand about trauma

17:48 Trauma, discomfort, and resilience

21:48 How the body remembers painful experiences

23:14 When biblical teaching reopens old wounds

25:34 Teaching Scripture when it has been weaponized

27:20 When congregations hurt their leaders

32:26 Pastoral boundaries, burnout, and compassion fatigue

34:15 Why pastors are expected to “take the hits”

36:02 Church abuse and distrust of pastors

38:07 Creating churches that understand trauma

41:07 Recognizing and responding to someone’s pain

43:15 Why “calm down” rarely helps

46:12 The emotional demands of caring for others

48:33 A sports detour

49:43 Seven criticisms directed at the Apostle Paul

52:54 Paul’s physical appearance and a disability hypothesis

58:13 Reading Paul’s rumination through the lens of trauma

59:10 Is Paul’s response a model to follow?

62:34 Closing thoughts and the book

See Privacy Policy at https://art19.com/privacy and California Privacy Notice at https://art19.com/privacy#do-not-sell-my-info.

Reflections